Can an Orc Defy Sauron? The Rings of Power Is Testing One of Tolkien’s Hardest Questions
Spoiler notice: Contains spoilers for The Rings of Power Season 2 and information officially discussed ahead of Season 3. No unaired Season 3 plot outcomes are revealed.
Can an Orc turn against Sauron without becoming one of the good guys? That is a far more interesting question than whether an Orc can write poetry.
The Rings of Power is introducing Marnûkh, an Orc connected in its new interviews to Adar's hope for a people outside Sauron's rule. That creates a difficult problem for the series: resisting a tyrant does not erase earlier violence or make a possible ally automatically trustworthy. The character could give Tolkien's old moral questions a political shape.
Prime Video has confirmed Marnûkh as a mysterious new character for Season 3, which begins November 11. The more provocative details come from interviews: the showrunners say some Orcs fear Sauron’s rule and still imagine a future outside it. That makes Marnûkh a potential ally of the Elves. It does not make him trustworthy.
Adar’s dream did not end with Adar
Season 2 gave the Orcs something the screen versions of Middle-earth rarely allow them: a political ambition beyond serving a Dark Lord. Adar wanted a home for his people. His methods were brutal, and the show never erased the suffering he inflicted, but he also saw the Uruk as beings with their own interests rather than disposable weapons.
That vision seemed to collapse when Sauron manipulated Adar’s followers into killing him. Yet the showrunners told Nerdist on October 29 that the desire for an independent Orc nation persists. J.D. Payne specifically identified Marnûkh as a character through whom that unfinished story will continue.
An Orc who resists Sauron's domination still has to answer for his actions. Political resistance does not imply friendship with the Elves or forgiveness for past cruelty. Any overlap between his goals and Galadriel's would be an alliance of interests, with trust still in dispute.
Radio Times reported in an October 9 interview that Young described Marnûkh as one of Sauron’s generals, a figure whose motives are deliberately difficult to read. The actor also declined to explain his connection to Adar, beyond confirming that Adar is mentioned. That uncertainty should survive into the audience’s expectations: a defector is not automatically a hero.
Tolkien’s Orcs were never a simple philosophical problem
The familiar screen image of the Orc is a creature made for battle, cruelty and obedience. Tolkien’s books often present Orcs as vicious antagonists. But he also gave them recognizable fears, grudges, arguments and desires. In The Two Towers, Shagrat and Gorbag complain about their superiors and imagine getting away from the war to live on their own terms. Their imagined freedom is hardly noble; they still dream of plunder. In The Return of the King, the conflict between Orcs turns murderous. Tolkien makes room for their self-interest without asking readers to mistake it for goodness.
Tolkien also struggled with their origin. If evil cannot create life from nothing, what exactly are Orcs? And if they are thinking creatures with wills of their own, can every one of them be condemned from birth? In his later writings, collected in Morgoth’s Ring, Tolkien considered the possibility that Orcs were not evil in their original nature, while leaving their prospects for redemption deeply uncertain. His correspondence likewise shows him wrestling with the moral and theological implications rather than handing down a neat, final answer.
None of this means Tolkien wrote an Orc redemption narrative like the one viewers might imagine for Marnûkh. He did not. Nor does it prove that a kindly, misunderstood Orc would fit seamlessly into his stories. It does mean that asking whether an Orc possesses moral agency is not a question invented by modern television writers.
The real test is not sympathy. It is responsibility.
The October 29 Nerdist interviews offer an intriguing glimpse of how the series approaches the Orcs physically as well as morally. Movement director Tallulah Holly-Massey described bodies shaped by confinement, injury and pain. The production is trying to make oppression visible in how these characters move, not merely in what they say.
The production's attention to Orc suffering gives the series a chance to examine moral agency. Orcs experience domination and inflict terrible harm themselves. A meaningful portrayal of Marnûkh needs to make his choices carry consequences for other characters; charm and sympathy alone would flatten that conflict.
Galadriel and Arondir are especially well placed to test that distinction. Both have suffered at the hands of Orcs, and neither can reasonably be expected to offer instant forgiveness. A story in which they must evaluate Marnûkh’s information while questioning his motives would be richer than a simple lesson about looking past appearances.
What Season 3 has — and has not — confirmed
Amazon’s official synopsis places Season 3 five years after the fall of Eregion. Sauron’s forces have overrun much of Middle-earth, and he is working in Barad-dûr to forge the One Ring. For those dates, see our Season 3 release schedule.
Marnûkh’s allegiance, ultimate intentions and fate remain unconfirmed. The series has not demonstrated that he will be redeemed, that he will betray the Elves, or that his story represents Tolkien’s definitive answer to the nature of Orcs. The official preview establishes a character and a conflict, while his eventual choices remain undisclosed.
An Orc who refuses Sauron may still demand trust he has not earned. Making Galadriel weigh the value of his information against the cost of believing him would give Marnûkh a meaningful role without simplifying his past or the conflict.
Sources
Prime Video's Season 3 preview introduces Marnûkh as an Orc who may not be what he seems; the character's ultimate choices remain unconfirmed.

Join the conversation
Share your thoughts on this story. Please keep the discussion thoughtful and respectful.